Free Assessment: Is My Parent Emotionally Immature? →

Disentangling From an Emotionally Immature Parent

Dr. Lindsay Gibson on compassionate detachment, the things that set emotionally immature parents off, and how much care you owe an aging parent.

By Academy Of Self Help

“You can still show compassion… but don't let your empathy run away with you.”
Dr. Lindsay C. Gibson, Academy Of Self Help Q&A

Dr. Lindsay Gibson answers Academy Of Self Help listener questions.

Explore this conversation with Lindsay C. Gibson, including its transcript

A parent who relies on you for emotional regulation

Emotionally immature adults count on other people to stabilize them and keep their self-esteem in good shape. When they’re dysregulated, they rely on your empathy to help them recenter.

Because they regulate their emotions so poorly, this can go on for a lifetime. For them, leaning on you is a way to borrow your strength until they feel steady again. But for you, Dr. Gibson says, it can feel like your empathy is being “wrung dry.”

Signs you're carrying a parent's emotions

A reminder that emotional immaturity lives on a wide spectrum, so not every experience below will be present for every parent.

01

You find yourself bracing every time they visit or call.

02

They make you feel like if you don't do what they want, you're failing or abandoning them.

03

Their distress feels like an emergency you have to fix.

04

They demand so much of you, but rarely, if ever, connect on a more meaningful level.

05

You have the same arguments or fights over and over again.

06

Their mood dominates your interactions. If they're not happy, nobody's happy.

Stepping away, or staying without absorbing

Dr. Gibson describes two ways to protect yourself when a parent overwhelms you with their emotional immaturity.

Step away

You always have the right to protect your emotional well-being and say something like: I know that you're hurting. I wish I could be of help right now, but I need to take care of myself.

  • It doesn't mean you're abandoning them.
  • You're not a bad person for taking care of yourself.
  • It becomes easier once you accept that you have the right to protect your own energy
  • When you take time away you see that their distress will find somewhere else to go.

Compassionate detachment

You may choose to stay physically, but you “leave inside.” You keep some feeling for them without wringing out your soul trying to make it better.

  • Treats them as a grown adult, without the duty you'd feel toward a small child's feelings
  • Sees the pattern as an ongoing endless quest for what they didn't get as children
  • Keeps the relationship on a controlled basis
  • Protects your heart from someone clinging to it like a life raft

What sets an emotionally immature parent off

Think about what threatens a small child, and you’ll know what threatens every human being: insecurity about what will happen to them, whether they’re still loved, whether they’ve been bad, whether people want them around.

The difference is in the reaction. Children and emotionally immature adults react involuntarily. They lack the maturity to feel something without showing it, or to express it in a way that works for the people around them.

Dr. Gibson says they’re especially sensitive to feeling accused of being wrong, mean or self-centered, because in their minds that isn’t what’s happening. They believe they’re right, and they believe they’re responding to you even when they’re talking about themselves. Anything that doesn’t leave them feeling better about themselves can set them off.

What’s missing is the ability to observe themselves: the self-reflection and self-control to hold back the first reactive response. You probably already know where the tripwires are. As Dr. Gibson points out, you start to feel uncomfortable as soon as a conversation gets near one, because you’ve been exposed to them so often.

How much care do you owe an aging parent?

“You always have a choice about who you’re going to take care of in your life.” With aging parents, their vulnerability and fragility can make that choice feel like a duty.

Dr. Gibson asks you to weigh your own mental health, your emotional limits, and your history with this person. A behavior that would seem minor to someone else can be unbearable after a lifetime of it.

If you’re giving more care than you have the strength for, Dr. Gibson says you face some hard decisions. She calls therapy or group support “imperative,” along with a good friend or partner who can help you decide what you can do, and how much, before your own health starts going downhill.

Protect your free time and downtime, and plan respite or backup in advance. It takes effort and sometimes money, but Dr. Gibson considers it well spent if it preserves your mental health.

She also suggests being real with your parent when caregiving forces more closeness than you want. Trying to be a certain kind of child to them is exhausting, and it doesn’t help anyone.

Deciding whether to tell an aging parent the truth about your childhood? Read Speaking Your Truth To Aging Emotionally Immature Parents →

Frequently asked questions

Is compassionate detachment the same as going no contact?

They're separate choices. Detachment happens inside you while contact continues. If contact itself has become unworkable, the family estrangement guide covers that decision.

Read the family estrangement guide

Does setting limits mean I don't love my parent?

In Gibson's words: “It doesn't mean anything about your love for your parent or your willingness to assist them. It's just that we have to work within our limits.”

Where can I read more about disentangling?

Gibson's book Disentangling From Emotionally Immature People (2023) is devoted to it.

Who is Dr. Lindsay Gibson?

Dr. Lindsay C. Gibson is a clinical psychologist and the author of Adult Children of Emotionally Immature Parents. This page draws on her answers in an Academy Of Self Help listener Q&A.

Read the full profile: Who Is Dr. Lindsay Gibson?

Still getting pulled back in?

The Healing From Emotionally Immature Parents course works through these patterns step by step, with exclusive interviews with Dr. Gibson.

Related Guides